Victory for Homeowner in Insurance Dispute

1

This stance was later annulled by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), which not only contested the insurer’s analysis but also highlighted its failure to document its assertions, leading to undue procrastination.

The dispute originated when the homeowner filed for claims in December 2022 subsequent to discovering her property profoundly vandalized by a former tenant. The cost of restorations was quoted at $15,873, evidence of which was presented via quotations and valid tax invoices. Chubb recognized the legitimacy of repair costs for the fire equipment and flooring, but denied responsibility for other damages, including those incurred on the property’s door, suggesting these were all covered by another contents policy. The homeowner, however, maintained the damages were related to the tenant.

Upon examining the records, AFCA contravened the insurer's claim that a more appropriate coverage applied. Nevertheless, in one scenario involving damage to a door, AFCA concurred with information suggesting the owner’s prior knowledge, hence her need to lodge it as a separate claim. Chubb insisted that a status report presented signs of wear and tear not inclusive in the policy coverage, yet neglected to provide said report as evidence, thereby weakening their argument.

The judgment articulated by AFCA indicated that the insurer had ample opportunities to exhibit pertinent documentation, especially since they were warned of potential unfavorable inferences being drawn if they failed to proffer the requested information within the specified timeframe. Chubb’s omission led to reliance on the homeowner's pre-tenancy condition report, which AFCA found convincingly didn't show the alleged pre-existing damage.

The tension culminated in a mandate requiring Chubb to remit $12,628 to the homeowner, after the policy excess deduction. Moreover, for the troubles wrought by delayed processes, less-than-adequate claims management, and lackluster communication, an added compensation of $3,500 was awarded to the claimant. This recompense was attributed to the significant impact on the homeowner, circumventing her reasonable expectations and encroaching on her serenity and overall wellbeing.

AFCA's determination underscored that the industry's standard of conduct was significantly breached, resulting in excessive delay and marked inconvenience that entangled the homeowner’s peace of mind and rightfully due claim resolution process.

Published:Saturday, 10th Feb 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Cyber Insurance Becomes Essential Amid Rising Digital Threats

12 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

The recent cyberattack on Fortnum Private Wealth, accompanied by ASIC's legal action, has spotlighted the critical risks cyber threats pose to financial advice companies in Australia. With digital integration intensifying across the finance sector, the owner of Fortnum, Entireti, plans to defend the case, underscoring the necessity for ongoing vigilance in cybersecurity measures. - read more

Swiss Re Foresees Rising Premiums Amid Increasing Global Risks

10 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In a comprehensive analysis, Swiss Re Institute predicts that global property and casualty insurance premiums will rise in tandem with GDP over the upcoming decade. This growth is driven by amplified natural catastrophe losses, asset accumulation, and heightened economic and litigation claims inflation. The institute's report outlines the evolving insurance landscape amid increasing global risks. - read more

Insurance Council of Australia Assists NSW Flood Claimants

09 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In response to the devastating floods that swept across New South Wales' Mid North Coast in May, the Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) is taking proactive steps to support the affected residents. Insurers, organised by the ICA, will be meeting with flood victims in Kempsey, Taree, and Port Macquarie to provide guidance and support as they navigate their insurance claims. - read more

Ombudsman Upholds Policyholder’s Claim Despite Fraud Allegations

08 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

A motor insurance policyholder has won a significant dispute over fraud allegations, with the industry ombudsman ruling in favour of a payout following a controversial car accident claim. The case revolved around an incident where the claimant's wife crashed at an intersection one evening, reportedly failing to yield. The lack of photographic evidence due to shock and subsequent involvement of towing services complicated matters. - read more

NM Insurance Secures Growth with Five-Year Zurich Partnership

05 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In a strategic move set to bolster its market position, NM Insurance has announced a five-year agreement with capacity provider Zurich, positioning itself for further growth and increased broker confidence in its success. Since its establishment two decades ago as Nautilus Marine Insurance Agency, NM Insurance has expanded its focus beyond the recreational boat market in Australia, branching into New Zealand and diversifying into the commercial marine, caravan, and motorcycle sectors. - read more

Empower Your Cyber Knowledge with CFC's Free Masterclass

03 Sep 2025: Paige Estritori

In an era where cyber threats are increasingly sophisticated, CFC Underwriting Limited has unveiled a unique opportunity for brokers to fortify their expertise through its newly launched Cyber Masterclass. This initiative offers a flexible, on-demand video learning series designed to advance brokers into proficient cyber insurance specialists at their convenience. - read more

Click for more Insurance News