Farm Insurance :: News
SHARE

Share this news item!

Victory for Homeowner in Insurance Dispute

Victory for Homeowner in Insurance Dispute

Victory for Homeowner in Insurance Dispute?w=400
In a compelling reversal, a homeowner emerged victorious in a disagreement over an insurance claim for malicious damage to her residence, prompting significant compensation from the insurer.
Chubb Insurance initially resolved to honor a claim just partly, covering a meager sum of $2,431 for specific damages.
However, it declined to acknowledge other necessary repairs, attributing them to earlier existing damage ostensibly not enclosed by the policy.

This stance was later annulled by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), which not only contested the insurer’s analysis but also highlighted its failure to document its assertions, leading to undue procrastination.

The dispute originated when the homeowner filed for claims in December 2022 subsequent to discovering her property profoundly vandalized by a former tenant. The cost of restorations was quoted at $15,873, evidence of which was presented via quotations and valid tax invoices. Chubb recognized the legitimacy of repair costs for the fire equipment and flooring, but denied responsibility for other damages, including those incurred on the property’s door, suggesting these were all covered by another contents policy. The homeowner, however, maintained the damages were related to the tenant.

Upon examining the records, AFCA contravened the insurer's claim that a more appropriate coverage applied. Nevertheless, in one scenario involving damage to a door, AFCA concurred with information suggesting the owner’s prior knowledge, hence her need to lodge it as a separate claim. Chubb insisted that a status report presented signs of wear and tear not inclusive in the policy coverage, yet neglected to provide said report as evidence, thereby weakening their argument.

The judgment articulated by AFCA indicated that the insurer had ample opportunities to exhibit pertinent documentation, especially since they were warned of potential unfavorable inferences being drawn if they failed to proffer the requested information within the specified timeframe. Chubb’s omission led to reliance on the homeowner's pre-tenancy condition report, which AFCA found convincingly didn't show the alleged pre-existing damage.

The tension culminated in a mandate requiring Chubb to remit $12,628 to the homeowner, after the policy excess deduction. Moreover, for the troubles wrought by delayed processes, less-than-adequate claims management, and lackluster communication, an added compensation of $3,500 was awarded to the claimant. This recompense was attributed to the significant impact on the homeowner, circumventing her reasonable expectations and encroaching on her serenity and overall wellbeing.

AFCA's determination underscored that the industry's standard of conduct was significantly breached, resulting in excessive delay and marked inconvenience that entangled the homeowner’s peace of mind and rightfully due claim resolution process.

Published:Saturday, 10th Feb 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Impact of Trump Tariffs on Global Insurance Industry Impact of Trump Tariffs on Global Insurance Industry
11 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

According to Swiss Re’s latest Sigma report, the growth of property and casualty premiums is moderating in both Australia and globally. This moderation is primarily driven by a slowdown in rate hikes. Additionally, the Trump administration's America First trade policy is putting further pressure on the insurance sector. - read more
Navigating Changes in Australia's Life Insurance Advice Landscape Navigating Changes in Australia's Life Insurance Advice Landscape
10 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The conversation on the shifting dynamics in Australia's life insurance advice sector featured Zurich Australia's head of adviser channel, Kieran Forde, and Hayes & Co director, Katherine Hayes. They engaged with editor Chris Dastoor to spotlight the current market conditions and future prospects for financial advisers in this domain. - read more
ASIC Challenges Federal Court's 'Fair Term' Ruling ASIC Challenges Federal Court's 'Fair Term' Ruling
09 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) is appealing a Federal Court decision regarding the wording of a 'pre-existing condition' clause in certain HCF Life insurance products. The court previously determined that while the wording had the potential to mislead consumers, it did not constitute an unfair contract term under the current laws set out in the ASIC Act 2001. - read more
ICA Advocates for Strata Law Reform in the ACT to Enhance Building Management ICA Advocates for Strata Law Reform in the ACT to Enhance Building Management
08 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The Insurance Council of Australia (ICA) is urging the Australian Capital Territory (ACT) to adopt strata transparency regulations, aiming to enhance oversight of building repairs and maintenance by owners’ committees. This call was made during a parliamentary inquiry, where the ICA pushed for measures akin to recent legislative changes in New South Wales. - read more
Tasmanian Government Insurance Proposal Faces Industry Backlash Tasmanian Government Insurance Proposal Faces Industry Backlash
07 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The Tasmanian government's recent proposal to establish a state-run insurance entity has drawn significant criticism from key players in the insurance industry. The plan, spearheaded by Premier Jeremy Rockliff, aims to expand the Motor Accidents Insurance Board into a broader service named TasInsure, offering products including home and contents insurance, small business coverage, and more. The RACT, a major player in Tasmania's insurance sector, expressed considerable concern, labelling the initiative as a simplistic answer to complex problems. - read more
Asbestos Scare Leaves Hospitality Business Uninsured Asbestos Scare Leaves Hospitality Business Uninsured
04 Jul 2025: Paige Estritori

The discovery of asbestos-contaminated mulch in a Sydney park led to the cancellation of a festival, resulting in significant financial losses for a hospitality business. Despite these setbacks, the company's claim for coverage under its business interruption (BI) policy was rejected. - read more



Farm Insurance Articles

Essential Coverage vs. Optional Add-ons: Balancing Protection and Costs Essential Coverage vs. Optional Add-ons: Balancing Protection and Costs
For Australian farmers, having the right insurance coverage isn't just a safety net—it's an integral part of sustaining their livelihood. Natural disasters, unpredictable climate conditions, and the inherent risks of agricultural production underline the critical importance of robust insurance for the agricultural community. As farmers navigate the complexities of insurance, understanding the basics becomes the first step toward securing their assets and ensuring the continuity of their operations. - read more
Livestock Insurance for Aussie Farmers: What You Need to Know Livestock Insurance for Aussie Farmers: What You Need to Know
Livestock farming is a significant part of the Australian agriculture industry. As with any business, farmers face numerous risks such as disease, death, theft or extreme weather events, which could cause damage or loss to their livestock assets. Livestock insurance provides cover against these risks, ensuring that farmers are financially protected from any potential financial losses, which could devastate their livelihoods. - read more
The Ultimate Guide to Affordable Farm Insurance for Australian Farmers The Ultimate Guide to Affordable Farm Insurance for Australian Farmers
Welcome to 'The Ultimate Guide to Affordable Farm Insurance for Australian Farmers.' As stewards of the vast Australian countryside, farmers face an array of unique challenges and risks. Every day, they grapple with the forces of nature, the volatility of the markets, and the complexities of modern agricultural operations. - read more
Agribusiness Risk: Liability Issues Facing Australian Farmers Today Agribusiness Risk: Liability Issues Facing Australian Farmers Today
The agricultural sector in Australia carves a significant portion of the country's economy, contributing to its GDP and providing employment across rural and suburban areas. Thus, navigating the complexities of agribusiness is not just a matter of crop cultivation and livestock management, but also of understanding the intricate web of liability risks that come with the terrain. - read more
How to Choose the Right Farm Insurance Policy for Your Needs How to Choose the Right Farm Insurance Policy for Your Needs
Farm insurance is a type of coverage designed specifically for the unique risks and operations involved in farming. It encompasses protection for farm dwellings, equipment, livestock, and crops, offering a tailored approach that reflects the diverse needs of farm owners. This coverage can help safeguard your livelihood against unforeseen events that could disrupt farm operations or result in significant financial losses. - read more
When the Rain Doesn't Come: Financial Planning Tips for Persistent Drought When the Rain Doesn't Come: Financial Planning Tips for Persistent Drought
For farmers across rural Australia, the unyielding dry spells brought on by persistent drought conditions are not just an environmental concern but a significant financial challenge. Effective financial planning becomes a cornerstone strategy for ensuring the resilience and longevity of these crucial agricultural businesses. The prickling heat and parched earth serve as stark reminders of nature's capacity to impact livelihoods, especially when the rain doesn't grace the farmlands for extended periods. - read more
Preparing for the Worst: Developing a Comprehensive Disaster Response Plan for Your Farm Preparing for the Worst: Developing a Comprehensive Disaster Response Plan for Your Farm
As a farmer, you know that unexpected events can have a significant impact on your farm and your livelihood. Natural disasters, such as floods, fires, droughts, and storms, can occur at any time and have devastating consequences. That's why it's crucial to have a comprehensive disaster response plan in place to protect your property, assets, and, most importantly, your loved ones and livestock. - read more
5 Key Types of Farm Insurance Policies for Australian Farmers 5 Key Types of Farm Insurance Policies for Australian Farmers
As an Australian farmer, understanding the necessity of farm insurance is crucial to protecting your livelihood. The agricultural sector is inherently fraught with risks, ranging from natural disasters to the unpredictable market. Farm insurance serves as a vital safety net, safeguarding your farm's infrastructure, crops, livestock, and more. - read more
Understanding Farm Equipment Insurance: What Rural Australians Need to Know Understanding Farm Equipment Insurance: What Rural Australians Need to Know
Farm equipment insurance is crucial for rural Australians who rely on their machinery for agricultural productivity. This insurance provides a safety net, helping to mitigate the financial risks associated with equipment loss or damage. - read more
The Impact of Weather on Farm Insurance Rates: What You Should Know The Impact of Weather on Farm Insurance Rates: What You Should Know
Farming in Australia is a dynamic venture that requires careful planning and management. One of the crucial aspects every Australian farmer should consider is farm insurance. It provides a safety net against potential financial losses arising from various risks. These include natural disasters, damage to crops, livestock issues, and accidents on the farm property. - read more
Top 10 Ways Australian Farmers Can Slash Insurance Costs Without Risking Coverage Top 10 Ways Australian Farmers Can Slash Insurance Costs Without Risking Coverage
Welcome to our definitive guide for Australian farmers on managing one of the most crucial aspects of their business: insurance. As a cultivator of the land, you're no stranger to the unpredictability of nature and the market. From intense weather events to fluctuating market demands, your line of work comes with its unique set of risks. Hence, safeguarding your livelihood with the right insurance is not just important—it's essential. - read more
The importance of income protection insurance for hobby farmers The importance of income protection insurance for hobby farmers
As a hobby farmer, you may not rely on your farm for your main source of income. Perhaps you have a full-time job but enjoy farming as a way to supplement your income and pursue a passion. However, just because farming is a hobby does not mean there aren't risks involved. In fact, hobby farmers face many of the same risks as commercial farmers, such as injury, illness, loss of crops or livestock, and damage to property. - read more

Need a Quote?
Start your free farm insurance quote comparison here.
Farm Type:
Postcode:

Knowledgebase
Elimination Period:
The time period between an injury and the receipt of benefit payments from an insurer, particularly in disability insurance.