Victory for Homeowner in Insurance Dispute

1

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

This stance was later annulled by the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA), which not only contested the insurer’s analysis but also highlighted its failure to document its assertions, leading to undue procrastination.

The dispute originated when the homeowner filed for claims in December 2022 subsequent to discovering her property profoundly vandalized by a former tenant. The cost of restorations was quoted at $15,873, evidence of which was presented via quotations and valid tax invoices. Chubb recognized the legitimacy of repair costs for the fire equipment and flooring, but denied responsibility for other damages, including those incurred on the property’s door, suggesting these were all covered by another contents policy. The homeowner, however, maintained the damages were related to the tenant.

Upon examining the records, AFCA contravened the insurer's claim that a more appropriate coverage applied. Nevertheless, in one scenario involving damage to a door, AFCA concurred with information suggesting the owner’s prior knowledge, hence her need to lodge it as a separate claim. Chubb insisted that a status report presented signs of wear and tear not inclusive in the policy coverage, yet neglected to provide said report as evidence, thereby weakening their argument.

The judgment articulated by AFCA indicated that the insurer had ample opportunities to exhibit pertinent documentation, especially since they were warned of potential unfavorable inferences being drawn if they failed to proffer the requested information within the specified timeframe. Chubb’s omission led to reliance on the homeowner's pre-tenancy condition report, which AFCA found convincingly didn't show the alleged pre-existing damage.

The tension culminated in a mandate requiring Chubb to remit $12,628 to the homeowner, after the policy excess deduction. Moreover, for the troubles wrought by delayed processes, less-than-adequate claims management, and lackluster communication, an added compensation of $3,500 was awarded to the claimant. This recompense was attributed to the significant impact on the homeowner, circumventing her reasonable expectations and encroaching on her serenity and overall wellbeing.

AFCA's determination underscored that the industry's standard of conduct was significantly breached, resulting in excessive delay and marked inconvenience that entangled the homeowner’s peace of mind and rightfully due claim resolution process.

Published:Saturday, 10th Feb 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Please Note: If this information affects you, seek advice from a licensed professional.

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Urgent Call for Enhanced Farm Safety Amid Rising Fatalities

29 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

In 2024, Australian agriculture faced a significant safety crisis, recording 72 farm-related fatalities-the highest in over two decades. This alarming statistic underscores the urgent need for enhanced safety protocols and awareness within the farming community. - read more

Soaring Insurance Costs Challenge Australian Farmers

29 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

Australian farmers are confronting a significant surge in insurance premiums, a trend largely attributed to the increasing frequency and severity of extreme weather events. Over the past few years, many farmers have reported that their insurance bills have more than doubled, with annual premiums exceeding $100,000. - read more

Revolutionising Crop Insurance with Satellite Technology

29 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

In a significant advancement for Australian agriculture, Insurance Facilitators (IF), a family-owned underwriting agency, has introduced a data-driven crop insurance solution leveraging satellite technology. This innovative approach aims to address longstanding challenges in the industry, including premium leakage and risk accumulation, by providing more accurate and efficient risk assessments. - read more

WFI and AgCarE Join Forces to Reward Sustainable Farming Practices

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

In a significant move towards promoting sustainable agriculture, WFI Insurance has partnered with AgCarE, a certification program developed by AgForce, to offer premium reductions to farmers who achieve AgCarE certification. This collaboration aims to enhance financial, environmental, and social outcomes for Australian farmers and rural communities. - read more

Rising Insurance Costs Challenge Australian Farmers as Extreme Weather Intensifies

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

Australian farmers are confronting a significant surge in insurance premiums, a trend largely attributed to the increasing frequency and severity of extreme weather events. Over the past few years, many farmers have reported that their insurance bills have more than doubled, with annual premiums exceeding $100,000. - read more

Diversifying Small Farms Open New Avenues for Insurance Brokers

21 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

The landscape of Australian agriculture is evolving as small commercial farms increasingly diversify their operations to enhance income and sustainability. This shift presents both challenges and opportunities for insurance brokers, as new ventures introduce complex risk management needs. - read more

Click for more Insurance News