Local Business Triumphs Over Insurer in Power Outage Dispute

3

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

The wrangle ensued after the butcher, located in Ballina, NSW, suffered power loss during the notorious Northern Rivers floods in early March 2022. This critical blackout resulted in the spoilage of the business's refrigerated stock and cessation of operations.

QBE, the insurance company involved, assigned blame to the torrential flood, fortifying its stance with a hydrologist's account deeming the blackout as a probable ramification of the floods. The narrative was apparently supported by a communication from the electricity provider EE, which highlighted interruptions due to the dire flooding and consequential severe damages to the grid infrastructure.

Challenging this assertion, the aggrieved butcher presented an alternative sequence of events, highlighting an intentional power shutdown orchestrated by EE to maintain civic safety in anticipation of the floods, a singular detail casting doubt on the direct correlation between floodwater and power loss.

This perspective is endorsed by an assessment from the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, casting ambiguity on the initial claims of the energy deficit’s timing and contesting the clear association with the flood event. It recognized that the local network's 'de-energizing' aligned with numerous protective activities spanning from damage assessment to essential community safety precautions.

Moreover, the hydrologist’s conjecture, although initially an aspect of QBE's argument, lacked conviction and specificity. No electrical inquiry was conducted, thus adulterating the assertion that flood-induced blackout was the unequivocal cause of the outage.

In a backdrop of dynamic interpretations, EE’s contemporary accounts marginally united with the insurer's diagnosis but delivered granular details attributing to a more comprehensive, and less flood-focused, synopsis of proceedings.

Debates also kindled around QBE’s assertion over the content benefit of the insurance policy, which covered physical loss or damage but not the 'consequential loss' due to it, suggesting that additional coverage was mandatory to protect against knock-on effects. QBE's stance was that the refrigeration stock damage fell into the latter category. However, the butcher's contention, fortified by the authoritative panel, avers that there was no substantive basis for separating the stock from the core property within the context of this claim.

Concluding the dispute, the authority panel exposed inadequacies in the insurance company’s rationalizations. They reprimanded QBE’s failure to thoroughly elucidate its defense and vehemently supported the butcher's position that the spoilt inventory was indeed covered as direct physical loss. The claim, they decreed, was firmly nestled within the innate protective spectrum of the insurance policy's provisions.

Published:Thursday, 29th Feb 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Please Note: If this information affects you, seek advice from a licensed professional.

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

IAG and Ag Guard Forge Partnership to Elevate Crop Insurance for Australian Farmers

14 Nov 2025: Paige Estritori

In a significant development for Australia's agricultural sector, Insurance Australia Group (IAG) has announced a strategic partnership with Ag Guard, a specialist rural underwriting agency. This collaboration will see Ag Guard managing the underwriting for IAG-owned CGU and WFI's crop insurance portfolios starting June next year. - read more

WFI Insurance and AgCarE Collaborate to Incentivize Sustainable Farming Practices

14 Nov 2025: Paige Estritori

In a move to promote sustainable agriculture, WFI Insurance has partnered with AgCarE, a certification program developed by AgForce, to offer premium reductions to farmers who achieve AgCarE certification. This collaboration aims to enhance financial, environmental, and social outcomes for Australian farmers and rural communities. - read more

Diversification in Small Farms Creates New Avenues for Insurance Brokers

14 Nov 2025: Paige Estritori

The landscape of Australian agriculture is undergoing a significant transformation as small commercial farms increasingly diversify their operations to enhance income and sustainability. This shift presents both challenges and opportunities for insurance brokers, as new ventures introduce complex risk management needs. - read more

Urgent Call for Enhanced Farm Safety Amid Rising Fatalities

29 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

In 2024, Australian agriculture faced a significant safety crisis, recording 72 farm-related fatalities-the highest in over two decades. This alarming statistic underscores the urgent need for enhanced safety protocols and awareness within the farming community. - read more

Soaring Insurance Costs Challenge Australian Farmers

29 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

Australian farmers are confronting a significant surge in insurance premiums, a trend largely attributed to the increasing frequency and severity of extreme weather events. Over the past few years, many farmers have reported that their insurance bills have more than doubled, with annual premiums exceeding $100,000. - read more

Revolutionising Crop Insurance with Satellite Technology

29 Oct 2025: Paige Estritori

In a significant advancement for Australian agriculture, Insurance Facilitators (IF), a family-owned underwriting agency, has introduced a data-driven crop insurance solution leveraging satellite technology. This innovative approach aims to address longstanding challenges in the industry, including premium leakage and risk accumulation, by providing more accurate and efficient risk assessments. - read more

Click for more Insurance News