Local Business Triumphs Over Insurer in Power Outage Dispute

3

The information on this website is general in nature and does not take into account your objectives, financial situation, or needs. Consider seeking personal advice from a licensed adviser before acting on any information.

The wrangle ensued after the butcher, located in Ballina, NSW, suffered power loss during the notorious Northern Rivers floods in early March 2022. This critical blackout resulted in the spoilage of the business's refrigerated stock and cessation of operations.

QBE, the insurance company involved, assigned blame to the torrential flood, fortifying its stance with a hydrologist's account deeming the blackout as a probable ramification of the floods. The narrative was apparently supported by a communication from the electricity provider EE, which highlighted interruptions due to the dire flooding and consequential severe damages to the grid infrastructure.

Challenging this assertion, the aggrieved butcher presented an alternative sequence of events, highlighting an intentional power shutdown orchestrated by EE to maintain civic safety in anticipation of the floods, a singular detail casting doubt on the direct correlation between floodwater and power loss.

This perspective is endorsed by an assessment from the Australian Financial Complaints Authority, casting ambiguity on the initial claims of the energy deficit’s timing and contesting the clear association with the flood event. It recognized that the local network's 'de-energizing' aligned with numerous protective activities spanning from damage assessment to essential community safety precautions.

Moreover, the hydrologist’s conjecture, although initially an aspect of QBE's argument, lacked conviction and specificity. No electrical inquiry was conducted, thus adulterating the assertion that flood-induced blackout was the unequivocal cause of the outage.

In a backdrop of dynamic interpretations, EE’s contemporary accounts marginally united with the insurer's diagnosis but delivered granular details attributing to a more comprehensive, and less flood-focused, synopsis of proceedings.

Debates also kindled around QBE’s assertion over the content benefit of the insurance policy, which covered physical loss or damage but not the 'consequential loss' due to it, suggesting that additional coverage was mandatory to protect against knock-on effects. QBE's stance was that the refrigeration stock damage fell into the latter category. However, the butcher's contention, fortified by the authoritative panel, avers that there was no substantive basis for separating the stock from the core property within the context of this claim.

Concluding the dispute, the authority panel exposed inadequacies in the insurance company’s rationalizations. They reprimanded QBE’s failure to thoroughly elucidate its defense and vehemently supported the butcher's position that the spoilt inventory was indeed covered as direct physical loss. The claim, they decreed, was firmly nestled within the innate protective spectrum of the insurance policy's provisions.

Published:Thursday, 29th Feb 2024
Source: Paige Estritori

Please Note: If this information affects you, seek advice from a licensed professional.

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Significant Reduction in Farm Liability Claims Reflects Enhanced Safety Practices

25 Jan 2026: Paige Estritori

Recent data from WFI Insurance indicates a substantial 75% decrease in farm liability claims over the past year, suggesting that Australian farmers are adopting more effective safety measures. This decline is particularly notable in incidents involving falls from height, which have reached their lowest level in four years. - read more

Steadfast Unveils Prevail: A New Era in High Net Worth and Farm Insurance

17 Jan 2026: Paige Estritori

In a significant development for the Australian insurance landscape, Steadfast has announced the launch of Prevail, a new specialist agency designed to cater to high net worth individuals and the farming sector. This initiative brings together three well-established underwriting agencies-Mansions, Dawes, and Argis-under a unified brand, aiming to provide comprehensive and tailored insurance solutions. - read more

Harland Green Launches Comprehensive All-Risk Insurance for Large-Scale Farms

17 Jan 2026: Paige Estritori

Harland Green, a newly established Lloyd's coverholder, has introduced an all-risk farm insurance package specifically designed for large commercial farming operations in Australia. This initiative aims to address the complex and evolving needs of the agricultural sector by offering comprehensive coverage that encompasses various aspects of farm operations. - read more

Allstate Underwriting and Mitsui Sumitomo Join Forces to Strengthen Farm Insurance Offerings

17 Jan 2026: Paige Estritori

Allstate Underwriting Agencies has announced a strategic partnership with Mitsui Sumitomo Insurance (MSI) to enhance its capacity in providing insurance solutions for medium, small, and hobby farms across Australia. This collaboration is set to bolster Allstate's presence in the farm pack market, offering tailored products that meet the specific needs of these farming segments. - read more

Rural Affinity and Munich Re Strengthen Agricultural Insurance in Australia

09 Jan 2026: Paige Estritori

In a significant development for Australia's agricultural sector, Rural Affinity has renewed its partnership with Munich Re Specialty - Global Markets under a new five-year agreement. This collaboration, which began in 2006, is set to enhance the availability and scope of agricultural insurance products across the country. - read more

WFI Insurance Highlights Significant Drop in Farm Liability Claims

09 Jan 2026: Paige Estritori

WFI Insurance has reported a notable decrease in farm liability claims across most categories, signaling a positive trend in safety practices within the Australian agricultural sector. The insurer observed a 75% reduction in falls from height over the past year, alongside a 30% decline in impact injuries, marking the lowest level in four years. - read more

Click for more Insurance News