Insurance Claim Denied Due to Evidence of Multiple Collisions

2

Hollard's initial acceptance of the claim was retracted following this discovery. In contrast, crash information from the other vehicle suggested the incidents happened roughly one minute apart. The insurer's expert highlighted inconsistencies in the impact heights, further pointing out that the vehicle's speed at the time of the incidents did not match the claimant's account.

The insurance policy mandated that coverage only applies to accidents resulting from a single, unexpected event. During a subsequent interview, the claimant acknowledged the possibility of additional impacts due to the car's movement post-collision, yet she was unable to provide a detailed account.

Hollard concluded that these discrepancies, along with expert analysis, indicated deceit on the claimant's part, invalidating her claim. The insured party contested the credibility of the expert report, labelling it misleading. However, the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (AFCA) upheld the insurer’s decision, deeming the expert findings as comprehensive and logically structured.

AFCA noted the differing time frames between the vehicles' crash data but asserted this did not undermine Hollard's position. The ombudsman stated he was unconvinced that the damage was the result of a singular accident, aligning instead with the evidence of two distinct impacts.

AFCA's ruling confirmed that regardless of whether the second crash occurred one or 11 minutes after the first, the incidents constituted separate events, leading to the denial of the insurance claim.

Published:Thursday, 14th Aug 2025
Source: Paige Estritori

Share this news item:

Insurance News

Clear

Broker Ordered to Compensate Client for Uninsured Fire Losses 15 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori A recent ruling mandates an insurance broker to pay nearly $300,000 in compensation to a client after an insurer, QBE, declined a fire claim and cancelled the policy due to nondisclosures. The fire, which occurred in October 2022, severely damaged the commercial premises. QBE asserted that they would have denied coverage had they known about asbestos on the property, among other unreported issues. - read more

Insurance Claim Denied Due to Evidence of Multiple Collisions 14 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori An insurance dispute arose when a driver was refused coverage for car damage after evidence showed involvement in multiple collisions, contrary to her claim. Initially, the woman filed a claim with Hollard Insurance, stating her car had collided once with another vehicle. However, the situation took a turn when forensic data from in-car technology revealed two separate impacts occurring 11 minutes apart. - read more

ASIC Considers Action as Professional Indemnity Insurance Transparency Falls Short 12 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori The Australian Securities and Investments Commission (ASIC) has voiced apprehension about the transparency of professional indemnity (PI) insurance amongst holders of the Australian Financial Services Licence (AFSLs). This concern arises from a recent market overview conducted to analyze PI insurance for AFSLs offering personal advice to retail clients. - read more

Traveller Triumphs in Insurance Dispute Over Unexpected Medical Detour 11 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori A savvy traveller has successfully challenged an insurance decision after having to make an impromptu stay in London due to a medical emergency. This came after the man needed urgent medical attention following a cat bite he sustained in Albania, which sent him to the UK capital for essential treatment. - read more

Revolutionising Life Insurance: Digital PMARs and Next-Gen Underwriting 11 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori In the age of instant digital services, where everything from basic necessities to luxury items can be delivered in a blink, the life insurance sector in Australia is poised for a transformative change. Historically plagued by lengthy processing times, the sector faces a persistent underinsurance gap, with over a million Australians lacking adequate life protection. The introduction of a digital Personal Medical Attendant Report (PMAR) by Acenda, formerly MLC Life, marks a significant stride towards addressing this challenge. - read more

Victorian Court Approves $34 Million Add-On Insurance Settlement 08 Aug 2025: Paige Estritori A Victorian court has ratified a $34 million settlement in a class action involving add-on insurance products sold by Suncorp. This settlement culminates the legal proceedings surrounding alleged unlawful sales practices. - read more